Mani Ratnam directed Ponniyin Selvan: Part 1 which is based on Kalki Krishnamuthy's novel of the same name released in multiple languages today. PS1 (as the film is known for non-Tamil viewers), seems to have particularly come under the bash-radar of its Telugu audience who have taken it upon themselves to compare it to SS Rajamouli's Baahubali movies starring Prabhas in the lead.
*mani saar fans and rajamouli saar fans uyira koduthu fighting on TL*— Arshad Wahid (@vettichennaiguy) September 30, 2022
mani saar and rajamouli saar @ them: pic.twitter.com/1HuvyRxBkJ
Such comparisons existed prior to PS1 release as well and director Mani Ratnam had stated back then that the success of Baahubali movies is a major boost for anyone, who wishes to take big budget period dramas. This was wrongly interpreted by a section as Mani Ratnam stating that the Ponniyin Selvan movies are inspired from the Baahubali movies [because the director used the word 'inspiration' for putting forth his point].
Now post PS1's release, the Telugu audience seems to be disappointed that Ponniyin Selvan is not another Baahubali. However Ponniyin Selvan was never a Baahubali to begin with. In an interview leading upto PS1's release, Mani Ratnam when questioned on the constant comparisons had clarified,
"Ponniyin Selvan is (about) Raja Raja Cholan. He is one of the greatest Kings of Tamil Nadu. So when you deal with (a story about) him, one has to deal honestly. So it (the movie) has to be realistic and the characters surrounding him also have to be real. The story is told through the eyes of Vanthiyathevan, who is a common man like us. The story travels through him, the royalty he meets..So this (Ponniyin Selvan) is a realistic creation. It will not have a fantasy world like Baahubali. Will not have superheroes. (PS1) will be much more down-to-earth. Everything will be in that tone - Be it the music, the locations, the visuals.
(Ponniyin Selvan) will have dirt, will have mud..This is not just telling a story about that time period (10th century)..Like Kalki, we are taking the audience to that time period. So it has to seem like (the incidents) happened during that time, it has to be realistic. So both (Ponniyin Selvan and Baahubali) are totally different genres. Both are historical but that (Baahubali) is complete fantasy, complete liberty and extraordinarily made.
This (Ponniyin Selvan) is not like that. It's realistic, it deals with drama. It deals with human emotions and values."
Ponniyin Selvan: Part 1 stars 'Chiyaan' Vikram, Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, Karthi, Trisha, Jayam Ravi in the lead and has AR Rahman for music. PS1 Review Here.
they're all about different things, appreciate the artistic elements of each film and keep it moving— b (@brownandbujji) September 30, 2022